Council refuses retention for Athlone family’s equestrian arena
Westmeath County Council has refused planning retention for an equestrian arena in Athlone which a local family said was being used to train horses for national and international showjumping competitions.
The application from Francis Derwin for retention of the 3,200 square metre equestrian sand arena in Fardrum was turned down by the local authority on October 29.
It its decision, the council said the applicant had "failed to adequately address concerns relating to the existing floodlighting, the operation of the equestrian facility, unauthorised works to an existing dwelling on the site, and the potential environmental impacts arising from the development".
Mr Derwin had sought retention approval for the equestrian facility which is accessed from the N52 at Tubbrit, Fardrum, Athlone. Retention approval was also sought for demolition works carried out to three agricultural structures at the site.
A letter submitted as part of the application said the equestrian arena was located on land that had been "farmed by the applicant over many years" and that the facility was "for their own private use only".
The occupation of Mr Derwin's family is horse training and farming, the council was told.
"The applicant specifically trains showjumping horses to perform at national and international showjumping competitions, with a family member making their livelihood as an international showjumping competitor," stated the letter submitted on behalf of Mr Derwin by Malachi Cullen Consulting Engineers.
It went on to say that, on average, five showjumping horses were being trained daily at the Fardrum location. "The horses are kept outside on the farmland and only exercised in the equestrian sand arena," it said.
The letter reiterated that the equestrian sand arena was for the applicant's "own private use only" and that it was "not made available for use by members of the public, including any form of tuition, hire, events, or commercial activity".
It also said the applicant had "undertaken to remove eight floodlighting columns" from the equestrian sand arena.
The retention application attracted one public submission, an objection, which was lodged by Melissa Murphy of Abbey Cottage, Glasson.
Ms Murphy said the scale of the equestrian arena, "coupled with intensive lighting and associated heavy traffic movements" was "entirely out of character with the local pattern of development" in "a rural residential area".
She said the "unauthorised nature of these works" had "already caused significant detriment to local amenity" and that "regularising such large-scale recreational/commercial-grade infrastructure" would set "an unacceptable precedent".
A planning report by Yvonne Haughey, Executive Planner with Westmeath County Council, referred to a previous retention bid that was submitted by Mr Derwin for the equestrian arena.
That application had been lodged last December and was "deemed withdrawn" by the council in August after the applicant failed to respond to a request for further information within the stipulated timeframe. Mr Derwin then submitted the new application for retention the following month.
Ms Haughey's report said certain planning issues which the council had raised in relation to the original retention application had still not been satisfactorily addressed.
She noted Mr Derwin had said eight floodlights at the site would be removed, however, she said, at the time of her report the floodlights remained in situ on the site.
"The applicant has not provided any supporting details, plans, specifications, timeframe for removal, or evidence that the lighting infrastructure will be permanently decommissioned," she said.
She also concluded Mr Derwin had not adequately addressed "concerns regarding the nature and extent of the equestrian use" of the site.
"No information has been submitted regarding the ownership of the horses, the frequency and scale of activities undertaken, associated vehicular movements, visitor numbers, or any future commercial use of the facility," her report stated.
"Furthermore, no sworn affidavit or statutory declaration has been submitted confirming that the arena will be restricted to private use and that no commercial equestrian activities will take place."
In addition, the planning report noted that the site in Fardrum "comprises a standalone equestrian facility" which was "physically removed from both the applicant's residence and the applicant's established equestrian enterprise located at The Derries" in Athlone.
"In such circumstances, the Planning Authority considers that the development cannot readily be characterised as incidental or ancillary to the normal enjoyment of a dwelling house," Ms Haughey's report said.
The local authority upheld its planning official's recommendation to refuse retention permission for the development.
Among the reasons set out by the council for refusing permission was that "the requested lighting assessment and Appropriate Assessment Screening Report," had not been submitted with the application, and that "sufficient information regarding the use and management of the facility" had not been provided.